Bill 9 is the Maui County law that ends vacation rentals in the county’s apartment-zoned condos. Its rule comes down to two dates. In the West Maui community plan area the rentals must cease on 1 January 2029, and everywhere else in the county, Kīhei, Wailea, Māʻalaea, Pāʻia, Hāna and Molokaʻi among it, on 1 January 2031. Hotels, validly existing timeshare units and permitted bed and breakfast homes and short-term rental homes are not what it phases out.
The open question is which condo complexes escape it. In June 2026 the Council created two hotel districts, H-3 and H-4, in which an apartment-zoned complex can keep renting once an ordinance rezones it, and it is deciding complex by complex. When we read the Council’s record on 20 November 2026, none of its eight rezoning bills had passed even a first reading. Below is every complex the Council’s referrals name, with the bill or resolution that names it and how far it had got.
What Bill 9 means for a stay
| Where you stay | What Bill 9 does |
|---|---|
| A hotel, or a rental a hotel district permits | Nothing: they are outside the phase-out |
| A timeshare unit | Nothing: validly existing timeshare units are exempt |
| A permitted bed and breakfast home or short-term rental home | Nothing: Bill 9 keeps both among the uses the apartment districts permit, under their own county permits |
| A vacation rental in an apartment-zoned condo in West Maui | Allowed to continue until 31 December 2028; must cease on 1 January 2029 |
| A vacation rental in an apartment-zoned condo anywhere else in the county | Allowed to continue until 31 December 2030; must cease on 1 January 2031 |
| A condo in a complex rezoned to H-3 or H-4 | Rentals may continue where the building meets the district’s conditions; no complex had been rezoned by 20 November 2026 |
The line between a vacation rental and a long-term rental is 180 days. The county’s code defines a transient vacation rental as occupancy of a dwelling or lodging unit “by transients for any period of less than one hundred eighty days”, so a stay of a month or three in an apartment-zoned condo phases out on the same dates as a week’s.
A stay that ends before the date for its side of the island is one the law lets run. For a stay after it, what matters is the complex, not the listing: whether its units are exempt, and whether the Council has passed an ordinance moving it into a hotel district. Bill 9’s exemptions, in its section 19.12.070.C below, are timeshare units, uses under a variance and uses otherwise permitted by law, and a booking made before the date is not among them. Which side of the island to stay on, and what kind of place, is on where to stay on Maui; the taxes on a room or a rental are on what a Maui trip costs.
What the law says
Bill 9, CD1, FD1 (2025) became Ordinance 5909. The Council passed it on first reading on 1 December 2025 and on final reading at a special meeting on 15 December 2025, both times by 5 votes to 3, and Mayor Richard Bissen signed it the same day. It took effect on approval: the county clerk’s certificate gives 15 December 2025 as its effective date. Councilmembers Gabe Johnson, Tamara Paltin, Keani Rawlins-Fernandez, Shane Sinenci and Nohelani Uʻu-Hodgins voted for it, and Chair Alice Lee, Vice-Chair Yuki Lei Sugimura and Councilmember Tom Cook against.
Its purpose, in its own words, is “to discontinue the use of Transient Vacation Rentals in Apartment Districts after a reasonable amortization period”. The new section 19.12.070 of the county code sets the dates:
“The uses will no longer be legally permitted or allowed as legally existing nonconforming uses and must cease on: a. January 1, 2029, in the West Maui community plan area; and b. January 1, 2031, for all remaining areas in the County.”
And the exemptions, in 19.12.070.C:
“Validly existing time share units, uses permitted and operating within the terms of a variance, and uses otherwise permitted by law are exempt from this section.”
The ordinance gave the county two deadlines of its own: notice by 1 March 2026 to every owner of property it phases out, mailed to the owner’s address for property tax and published in a newspaper two weeks running; and by 15 March 2026 a list of every parcel affected, from the director of finance to the Council, the planning director and the Mayor, updated each March until 2030.
The rentals it ends exist because of an exception made in 1989. Until 20 April 1989 vacation rentals were a permitted use in the apartment districts. Ordinance 1797 then required their buildings to be lived in long term, six months or more a year, except buildings that had certain county approvals by that date, and those exceptions let some multi-unit buildings keep renting to visitors. A state law of 2024, Act 17, lets Hawaiʻi’s counties phase out transient accommodations in any zoning district. The Council’s findings tie its decision to the county’s housing crisis, which the August 2023 wildfires deepened when more than 5,400 households were destroyed and 12,000 people displaced.
Which condos it covers: the Minatoya list
Bill 9 reaches the vacation rentals in the county’s A-1 and A-2 apartment districts. The county’s list of them is titled “Apartment District Properties Allowed to be Used for Short-Term Occupancy”, and the Planning Department’s papers call it the Minatoya list. The version dated 27 June 2024, which the Council attached to Ordinance 6008 as the list of properties that may qualify for the new hotel districts, names 104 properties, from Hana Kai Maui in Hāna and the Wailea Ekahi complexes to Kaʻanapali Royal, and totals 7,167 apartment-district vacation rental units. Ordinance 6008 has the Planning Department publish the list on its website.
Neither the ordinance nor the list treats it as the last word. The ordinance says the list “is not a confirmation of a zoning determination”, the list’s own footer says it “is subject to error” and that confirmation should come from the Department of Planning, and the department told the Council the list was not originally its own and may hold some inaccuracies.
Inside one complex, units can differ. The Planning Department’s report of 22 September 2026 says that on a property mixing timeshare and vacation-rental units, the timeshare units are exempt and the rest are subject to the phase-out unless the complex is rezoned. Maui Sunset in Kīhei, for one, held 45 timeshare units among its 225 in the county’s tax records.
The way out: the H-3 and H-4 hotel districts
Ordinance 6008, which began as Bill 88 (2026), created the two districts. The Council passed it on first reading on 5 June 2026 and on final reading on 19 June, and it took effect on 22 June 2026. The districts are “reserved for properties that had been zoned A-1 and A-2, respectively, with buildings or structures where transient vacation rentals had been permitted uses”, and they exist on every island of the county except Molokaʻi. The Maui, Lānaʻi and Molokaʻi planning commissions had each recommended against the bill creating them, on 24 February, 18 March and 8 April 2026, and the Council created them anyway.
Creating the districts rezoned nothing. A complex moves only when the Council passes an ordinance changing its zoning, from A-1 to H-3 or from A-2 to H-4, usually with a second bill amending its community plan, and the Maui Planning Commission makes its recommendation first. Even then, a building in H-3 or H-4 may host vacation rentals only if it meets four conditions, which the Planning Department describes as the ones the apartment districts set before Bill 9:
- its building permit, special management area permit or planned development approval was lawfully issued and valid on 20 April 1989;
- a vacation rental was legally run in at least one of its lawful units before 24 September 2020, by the county’s property tax classification or by payment of the state’s general excise and transient accommodations taxes;
- it rents no more rooms or units to visitors than it was allowed to on 7 January 2022;
- its owner or operator holds general excise and transient accommodations tax licenses and is current on the state and county taxes, fines and penalties for the rental.
The first 48 properties: Bills 169 to 176
The Council sent the first group to the Maui Planning Commission on 24 July 2026, in two resolutions. Resolution 26–110, CD1, FD1 named complexes mixing timeshare and vacation-rental units, complexes of timeshares only, leasehold complexes, single-owner properties and properties holding a variance. Resolution 26–111, CD1 named properties operating like hotels, with such things as a front desk, housekeeping and staff. Together they covered 48 properties with about 3,402 units.
On 22 September 2026 the commission recommended approving five and denying the rest. It found too little information on the single-owner properties’ parking, layout and units, and no objective standard for what makes a condo operate like a hotel. The Planning Department had backed more: as its letter of 13 October sums up its report and presentation of 22 September, it recommended the variance and timeshare properties, the five single-owner properties whose vacation rentals before 24 September 2020 the county’s tax records showed, and Maui Eldorado, whose community plan designation is already Resort Hotel, and left the mixed, leasehold and other hotel-like properties to the commission’s judgment.
Bills 169 to 172: the five the commission recommended
Before the Council’s Housing and Land Use Committee since 30 October 2026, as HLU-27, “as recommended by the Maui Planning Commission”.
| Complex | Address | Bills | Sent as | Planning Department | Commission, 22 September 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maui Schooner | 980 South Kihei Road, Kīhei | 169, 170 | Timeshares only | Approve | Approve |
| Kuau Plaza | 777 Hana Highway, Pāʻia | 169, 170 | Variance | Approve | Approve |
| Hono Koa | 3801 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina | 169, 170 | Timeshares only | Approve | Approve |
| Hale Kaanapali | 45 Kai Ala Drive, Kāʻanapali | 170 | Variance | Approve | Approve |
| Hana Kai Maui | 4865 Uakea Road, Hāna | 171, 172 | Operating like a hotel | Left to the commission | Approve |
In the department’s reading, four of the five are exempt from Bill 9 already: Maui Schooner and Hono Koa are timeshares throughout, and Kuau Plaza and Hale Kaanapali hold variances, granted on 22 March 1966 to operate a hotel resort and on 6 April 1965 for an apartment-hotel. For those two, the department said, the hotel district ends a reliance on entitlements issued over 50 years ago.
Bills 173 to 176: the ones the commission recommended denying
Before the same committee since 30 October 2026, as HLU-28. The commission recommended denying every property in these four bills.
| Complex | Address | Bills | Sent as | Planning Department | Commission, 22 September 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Maui Sunset | 1032 South Kihei Road, Kīhei | 173, 174 | Timeshare mix | Left to the commission | Deny |
| Maui Hill | 2881 South Kihei Road, Kīhei | 173, 174 | Timeshare mix; leasehold | Left to the commission | Deny |
| Kauhale Makai | 938 South Kihei Road, Kīhei | 173, 174 | Timeshare mix | Left to the commission | Deny |
| Kuleana (two parcels) | 3959 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina | 173, 174 | Timeshare mix; leasehold | Left to the commission | Deny |
| Paki Maui III | 3615 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina | 173, 174 | Timeshare mix; leasehold | Left to the commission | Deny |
| Paki Maui I & II | 3601 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina | 173, 174 | Timeshare mix; leasehold | Left to the commission | Deny |
| Wailea Inn | 2141 Iliili Road, Kīhei | 173, 174 | Single owner | Approve | Deny |
| Villa Moana | 1158 Uluniu Road, Kīhei | 173, 174 | Single owner | Approve | Deny |
| Aloha Villas | 1338 Uluniu Road, Kīhei | 173, 174 | Single owner | Approve | Deny |
| Waiohuli Beach Duplex | 64 West Lipoa Street, Kīhei | 173, 174 | Single owner | Approve | Deny |
| My Waii Beach Cottage | 2128 Iliili Road, Kīhei | 173, 174 | Single owner | Not without proof of rentals before September 2020 | Deny |
| Indo Lotus Beach House | 2216 South Kihei Road, Kīhei | 173, 174 | Single owner | Not without proof | Deny |
| Six homes named by address | 2131 Iliili Road; 1194 and 1178 Uluniu Road; 1444, 1440 and 1470 Halama Street, Kīhei | 173, 174 | Single owner | Not without proof | Deny |
| Wailea Ekahi I, II and III | 3300 Wailea Alanui Drive, Wailea | 175, 176 | Operating like hotels | Left to the commission | Deny |
| Wailea Ekolu | 10 Wailea Ekolu Place, Wailea | 175, 176 | Operating like a hotel | Left to the commission | Deny |
| The Palms at Wailea I | 3200 Wailea Alanui Drive, Wailea | 175, 176 | Operating like a hotel | Left to the commission | Deny |
| Kamaole Sands | 2695 South Kihei Road, Kīhei | 175, 176 | Operating like a hotel | Left to the commission | Deny |
| Papakea | 3543 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina | 175, 176 (a portion in 176) | Operating like a hotel | Left to the commission | Deny |
| Maui Eldorado | 2661 Kekaa Drive, Kāʻanapali | 176 | Operating like a hotel | Approve | Deny |
In the referral, but in none of the bills
The committee’s agenda names the properties in each of Bills 169 to 176, and these complexes from the 48 are in none of them: the four on Hauoli Street in Māʻalaea that the department listed as leasehold, Hono Kai, Kanaʻi A Nalu, Lauloa Maalaea and Milowai-Maʻalaea; Kahana Outrigger, Kahana Village, Hale Mahina Beach Resort, Maui Sands I, Maui Sands II (also known as Maui Sands Seaside), Mahina Surf and Lahaina Beach Club, on Lower Honoapiilani Road; Kaʻanapali Royal, on Kekaa Drive in Kāʻanapali; and Luana Kai and Kapu Townhouse in Kīhei. The commission recommended denying all of them.
Where the bills stood on 20 November 2026
Both groups of bills were on the agenda of the Council’s Housing and Land Use Committee on 19 November 2026. The meeting was recessed to the afternoon of Friday 20 November, and the agenda for that session still listed both groups, for the committee to consider recommending passage on first reading “with or without revisions”, or filing them. When we read the Council’s record early that morning, it showed no committee action on either group, and the committee’s list of its 2026 reports carried none on them. A bill the committee sends on still needs the full Council’s first reading and then its final reading, as Bill 9 and Bill 88 did.
The 32 shoreline complexes: Resolution 26–129
The second referral covers 32 condo complexes in Māʻalaea, Kīhei and West Maui. The Council adopted Resolution 26–129, CD1 by 5 votes to 4 at its meeting of 25 September 2026, recessed to Tuesday 29 September because of Hurricane Nolo’s approach, and an amendment to add two more West Maui properties failed by 4 votes to 5. Maui Now named the two as Nohonani, at 3723 Lower Honoapiilani Road, and Hoyochi Nikko, at 3901.
The resolution rezones nothing. It sends two bills to the Maui Planning Commission: one amending the Kīhei-Mākena and West Maui community plans, the other changing the zoning of the 32, by Maui Now’s account 19 of them from A-1 to H-3 and 13 from A-2 to H-4. The commission must hold hearings and make its recommendation before the Council takes final action, and if it recommends against the bills, Maui Now reported on 30 September 2026, the Council would need six of its nine votes to pass them, one more than voted for the referral. In the same report, Councilmember Uʻu-Hodgins, who chairs the housing committee and introduced the resolution, said the properties qualify because more than half of each building’s footprint lies in the state’s Sea Level Rise Exposure Area at 3.2 feet of sea-level rise, in a special flood hazard area or in the shoreline setback area, and the buildings were not originally meant as affordable or workforce housing. On 22 September the commission had asked that the coastal properties among the first 48 be treated the same as similar ones in Resolution 26–129 “in regard to coastal aspects”. The housing committee’s list of its 2026 reports, as it stood on 18 November 2026, carried none on a bill for the 32.
The 32, as the Council’s minutes list them:
| Complex | Address |
|---|---|
| Makani A Kai | 300 Hauoli Street, Māʻalaea |
| Maalaea Banyans | 190 Hauoli Street, Māʻalaea |
| Waipuilani | 1002 South Kihei Road, Kīhei |
| Kihei Bay Surf | 715 South Kihei Road, Kīhei |
| Leinaala | 998 South Kihei Road, Kīhei |
| Koa Resort II | 811 South Kihei Road, Kīhei |
| Kihei Resort | 777 South Kihei Road, Kīhei |
| Kihei Bay Vista | 679 South Kihei Road, Kīhei |
| Hale Mahialani | 7 Kaiau Place, Kīhei |
| Kamaole One | 2230 South Kihei Road, Kīhei |
| Hale Ili Ili | 2172 Iliili Road, Kīhei |
| Punahoa Beach Condominiums | 2142 Iliili Road, Kīhei |
| Hale Kai O’Kihei | 1310 Uluniu Road, Kīhei |
| Leilani Kai | 1226 Uluniu Road, Kīhei |
| Kihei Garden Estates | 1299 Uluniu Road, Kīhei |
| Waiohuli Beach Hale | 49 West Lipoa Street, Kīhei |
| Kihei Villa | 2135 South Kihei Road, Kīhei |
| Shores of Maui | 2075 South Kihei Road, Kīhei |
| Kihei Parkshore | 2037 South Kihei Road, Kīhei |
| Kanoe Apartments | 2050 Kanoe Street, Kīhei |
| Kahana Reef | 4471 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina |
| Makani Sands | 3765 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina |
| Kaleialoha | 3785 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina |
| Lokelani | 3833 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina |
| Hale Ono Loa | 3823 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina |
| Pikake | 3701 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina |
| Mahinahina Beach | 4007 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina |
| Polynesian Shores | 3975 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina |
| Noelani | 4095 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina |
| Hale Kai I | 3695 Lower Honoapiilani Road, Lahaina |
| Puʻunoa Beach Estates | 45 Kai Pali Place, Lahaina |
| Lahaina Roads | 1403 Front Street, Lahaina |
The dates in order
| Date | What happened, or happens |
|---|---|
| 1 December 2025 | Bill 9 passes first reading, 5–3 |
| 15 December 2025 | Final reading, 5–3; the Mayor signs it and it takes effect as Ordinance 5909 |
| 1 March 2026 | The county’s deadline to notify the owners it affects |
| 15 March 2026 | The director of finance’s deadline for the list of parcels it affects |
| 22 June 2026 | Ordinance 6008 (Bill 88) creates the H-3 and H-4 hotel districts |
| 24 July 2026 | Resolutions 26–110 and 26–111 send 48 properties to the Maui Planning Commission |
| 22 September 2026 | The commission recommends five and recommends denying the rest |
| 29 September 2026 | Resolution 26–129, CD1 sends 32 shoreline complexes to the commission, 5–4 |
| 30 October 2026 | Bills 169 to 176 go before the Housing and Land Use Committee |
| 19 and 20 November 2026 | The committee’s meeting on them, recessed from the 19th to the 20th |
| 31 December 2028 | Last day for apartment-district vacation rentals in West Maui |
| 1 January 2029 | They must cease in West Maui |
| 31 December 2030 | Last day for them everywhere else in the county |
| 1 January 2031 | They must cease everywhere else |